Launching new products can feel like placing a huge bet – one wrong assumption and you risk losing everything. Just look at the infamous Ford Edsel, a 1950s car designed to be revolutionary. Ford invested heavily – around $250 million – but ignored crucial customer insights gathered during research. The result? A spectacular failure costing over $350 million, all-in.

Concept testing helps you avoid becoming the next cautionary tale. 

By validating your ideas early, you make sure your product aligns closely with customer needs, saving you time, money, and frustration.

In this guide, you'll learn exactly what concept testing involves, how to do it effectively, explore real-world examples, and gain practical tips to make sure your next product resonates powerfully with your audience.

Key takeaways 

• Concept testing is a research method that helps you validate product ideas by gathering feedback directly from your target audience, reducing the risk of costly mistakes.

• Effective concept tests requires clearly defined and measurable goals, carefully selected participants, and a thoughtful combination of qualitative (open-ended feedback) and quantitative (rating scales) data.

• Select the right concept testing method based on your product’s development stage: early-stage ideas benefit from simple monadic or comparative tests, while advanced prototypes require detailed usability tests.

• Analyzing and synthesizing concept test results involves more than identifying the winning idea; it means understanding clearly why users prefer certain concepts, enabling better-informed product decisions.

What is concept testing?

Concept testing is a research method where customers provide feedback on a concept or idea during the consumer product testing phase – before it hits the market. Typically, in the product design cycle, this happens after ideation but before actual product development begins.

It's an effective way to realign the development process around your audience’s true needs and preferences. You can use concept testing in various situations:

• Early-stage validation: Gauge interest or appeal of a product idea to your target audience.

• Post-launch feature testing: Measure desirability and effectiveness of proposed features.

• Design element feedback: Assess reactions to specific elements (e.g. a chatbot that persists across screens).

• Pre-launch refinement: Fine-tune marketing materials, messaging, or identify potential quality assurance issues before the product goes live.

By systematically gathering audience feedback, concept testing helps ensure your decisions are customer-focused at every stage.

Start concept testing today with ready-made templates

Skip the guesswork! Access our library of expert-crafted usability testing templates and start gathering feedback immediately. From product concepts to feature validation, we've got you covered.

See templates

See templates

See templates

Concept testing benefits

Implementing concept testing in your product development process offers several significant advantages.It saves money by catching costly mistakes early

Concept testing significantly reduces financial risk by validating your product or idea early in development. The cost to fix an issue after release can be up to 100 times higher than addressing it during early design stages. By conducting concept tests, you identify fundamental issues – like unclear value propositions or unmet user needs – long before you invest significant resources, avoiding expensive reworks and product recalls.

It builds internal buy-in with data

Aligning your team on product direction can be difficult. Concept testing can provide clear, unbiased user data to guide decision-making – if a concept test reveals 70% of targeted users strongly prefer one design approach over another, internal debates become that much easier to resolve.

It encourages innovation by reducing the fear of failure

Concept testing allows you to validate ideas through low-risk experiments, so you can pursue bold, creative solutions. 

Because you can identify and discard unsuccessful concepts quickly, your team becomes more confident to push creative boundaries, knowing they can pivot easily based on real feedback.

It optimizes your product before it reaches customers

A good product can become exceptional with iterative refinement based on user feedback. Conducting concept tests – such as preference tests, prototype evaluations, or A/B comparisons – before launching helps you fine-tune details like pricing, messaging, usability, and visual appeal. 

This iterative approach ensures your product resonates strongly with your target market, maximizing chances of successful adoption.

It enhances user satisfaction by centering products around real needs

Products designed based on direct user input consistently achieve higher customer satisfaction. Concept tests directly reveal what your audience values most, what frustrates them, and what features or experiences they're willing to embrace. 

Building your product around these insights means users feel genuinely understood, increasing satisfaction, loyalty, and long-term retention.

It minimizes risk by reducing uncertainty

Concept testing provides clarity about potential user reactions before products enter the market. This proactive approach allows you to identify and address concerns, usability problems, or unclear messaging that could lead to customer confusion or dissatisfaction. 

By systematically collecting feedback early, you significantly reduce the uncertainty that typically accompanies new product launches, protecting your brand reputation.

It accelerates your time to market by clarifying priorities

Development delays often stem from unclear priorities or internal disagreements about what matters most to users. Concept testing brings focus by clearly revealing user preferences and pain points. 

When you know exactly what users value and what they find irrelevant, your team can confidently prioritize tasks, speeding up the development process and enabling faster market entry.

It remains beneficial throughout the entire product lifecycle

Concept testing isn’t limited to the early stages of product development – it remains useful even after you launch.

For instance, you can continually test new features, promotional messaging, or interface updates to maintain alignment with changing user expectations and market trends. 

This approach to continuous product discovery helps maintain relevance, ongoing improvement, and strong user engagement over the lifetime of your product.

How do you conduct a concept test: A step-by-step guide

The goal of concept testing is to methodically answer a critical question: "Is this a good idea?" Since concept testing aims to save significant resources down the road, it’s important not to rush the process.

Follow these clear steps for effective concept testing.

1. Set a goal for your test

Start by refining the broad question ("is this a good idea?") into a specific, measurable goal. Consider:

• Audience: Are you targeting your entire audience or a specific demographic segment?

• Purpose: Are you testing general appeal, potential usage, or willingness to purchase?

• Measurable success: Define suitable concept-stage metrics clearly, such as:

  • Purchase intent: Percentage of participants likely to purchase.

  • Concept appeal rating: Average rating or percentage finding the concept appealing.

  • Clarity: Percentage of participants who clearly understand the product benefits. 

  • Relevance: Percentage who find the concept relevant to their needs.

• Benchmark: Establish a numeric target, such as "Do at least 75% of participants find the concept appealing enough to consider purchasing?"

2. Create your test

Depending on your needs, your concept test may be unmoderated (e.g. a survey) or moderated (e.g. a user interview). Whichever format you choose, keep these tips in mind:

• Keep it brief: Maintain user attention by limiting the length and complexity of the test.

• Include open-ended questions: Avoid asking leading questions and encourage honest reactions. Examples include:

  • "What were your initial thoughts when viewing the concept?"

  • "Which features appealed to you most, and why?"

  • "Are there aspects you found confusing or unclear?"

  • "How likely are you to consider buying this product?"

• Visual clarity: Use clear, representative images to align users' understanding of your concept.

• Quantifiable metrics: Incorporate rating systems (e.g. Likert scales from "strongly favorable" to "strongly unfavorable") alongside qualitative questions.

Want to dive deeper into crafting effective concept testing questions? Check out our guide to writing concept testing questions for expert tips and real-world examples.

3. Recruit the right participants

The participants you recruit can directly impact the quality of your concept test results:

• Target the right audience: Use screener questions to ensure participants accurate represent your intended users or buyers.

• Include demographic diversity:Recruit from various demographic groups and user segments using multiple channels (e.g. targeted ads, social media, external panels) to avoid sampling biases and obtain balanced perspectives.

• Balance quantity and depth: Consider your research goals when choosing between methods, for example:

  • Moderated interviews: Deeper information from fewer participants.

  • Unmoderated surveys: Broader but shallower feedback from more participants.

4. Review and interpret your results

Proper analysis transforms raw data into actionable insights:

• Quantitative analysis: Review numeric data to spot clear patterns and trends.

• Qualitative analysis: Examine open-ended responses to understand user sentiment and underlying motivations.

• Benchmarking: Compare your results against previous tests or established benchmarks to measure improvements and identify areas for further refinement.

• Collaborative review: Share findings with multiple stakeholders to reduce individual bias and ensure comprehensive interpretation.

Concept testing types (and when to use each)

While the overall steps to concept testing are well-established, there are a few different frameworks to think through and possibly implement. They vary pretty widely in terms of application and scale. 

Monadic testing

In monadic testing, participants view just a single concept or idea and provide detailed feedback. Participants focus solely on this single concept without influence from competing ideas. 

However, because participants evaluate only one concept, it’s difficult to make direct comparisons between multiple concepts.

When it’s useful: Ideal for detailed feedback on a single, clearly defined concept, especially when you’ve already narrowed down your top choice.

Sequential monadic testing

Sequential monadic testing also involves participants evaluating concepts individually, but in this case, multiple concepts are presented one after another in a specific sequence. 

This method allows you to gather detailed feedback on multiple concepts. By controlling thepresentation order, it helps to minimize bias. 

However, this approach is time-consuming and impractical for evaluating many concepts.

When it’s useful: Best when you need in-depth feedback on several closely related concepts, with careful control of order effects.

Comparative testing

Also called preference testing, comparative testing involves presenting two or more concepts simultaneously. 

Participants provide feedback on each concept and indicate their preferences. Comparative testing simplifies direct comparison between concepts but can introduce bias, as participants' opinions might be influenced by the presence of alternative ideas.

When it’s useful: Most effective when you want a direct comparison to quickly determine user preference between multiple concepts.

Protomonadic testing

Protomonadic testing goes a step further by presenting participants with a working prototype rather than just an abstract concept. 

Participants interact directly with this prototype, offering feedback on usability and user experience. However, this method is more resource-intensive, requiring functional prototypes that accurately reflect the final product.

When it’s useful: Essential in the later stages of product development, when you want feedback on usability and overall user experience before full production begins.

Concept testing: Four real-world examples

Concept testing is such a broad idea that it can seem a little abstract. But remember, at its core, it’s really just taking a quick pause in the product development process at the right time to get a gut-check from users. 

Some of the world’s biggest brands use this process. 

Airbnb

Airbnb used concept testing to determine whether users preferred a horizontal or vertical layout for their search results page. Through testing, they found that users preferred the horizontal layout, and implemented it on their site. 

Micrsoft

Microsoft conducted comparative testing to determine the effectiveness of different taskbar designs, and ultimately used the results to inform the design of the taskbar in Windows 10. 

Amazon

Amazon extensively employed concept testing when developing the Amazon Echo and its voice assistant, Alexa. 

They tested various physical designs, voice tones, wake words, and even subtle interactions like LED color indications and the device's responsiveness to different accents. 

By carefully gathering customer feedback during these concept phases, Amazon refined Echo into a product that resonated deeply with customers, driving rapid adoption.

Lego

Lego regularly engages in concept testing through its "LEGO Ideas" platform, inviting users to submit, vote on, and give feedback on proposed LEGO set designs. Winning concepts are turned into commercially available products. For instance, user-submitted ideas such as the NASA Apollo Saturn V rocket and the Friends Central Perk café were developed into highly successful products based on direct consumer validation.

On a smaller scale, concept testing can be implemented in a variety of ways. Maybe it means running some new home page designs by a representative set of customers. It may mean designing a survey that gauges interest in a new product. Or it could be getting detailed feedback from a wide group around a few possible rebranding options. The magic of concept testing comes in taking the time to be intentional and methodical about the deliberations.

A preference test created in Lyssna, which asks participants to choose which homepage design they prefer.

Avoiding pitfalls in concept testing: Mistakes and fixes

If you follow the steps above closely, you’re well on your way to conducting an effective concept test. Still, it’s worth reviewing several common mistakes as a failsafe.

Undefined research goals

Reason: Without clearly defined objectives, concept tests become unfocused, making meaningful analysis difficult and resulting in vague or unusable insights.

Solution: Dedicate adequate time at the start of the process to establish clear, measurable goals. Define precisely what success looks like (e.g. 70% of users indicate strong interest in purchasing), ensuring clarity for both testing and analysis phases.

Testing with the wrong participants

Reason: Testing with participants who don’t accurately represent your intended audience generates misleading data and inaccurate conclusions.

Solution: Implement thorough screening questions to ensure your participants closely match your intended audience. If necessary, enlist external research panels to access representative user segments.

Poorly designed concept tests

Reason: Poor test design – such as overly long surveys, unclear or biased questions, or improper randomization – leads to unreliable data, participant fatigue, and misleading outcomes.

Solution: Always pilot-test your concept tests on a small subset of participants first. Use their feedback to refine questions, eliminate ambiguity, and ensure the design aligns clearly with your research goals before sharing with participants.

Using the wrong metrics

Reason: Selecting inappropriate metrics (e.g. using long-term retention or complex behavioral data at the concept stage) leads to results that don't accurately reflect the concept’s potential success.

Solution: Conduct stakeholder interviews beforehand, clarifying and confirming which metrics best align with your test’s specific objectives. 

Focus on clear, actionable metrics suitable to the early-stage nature of concept testing (e.g., purchase intent, clarity, appeal).

Misinterpreting the results

Reason: Results misinterpreted out of context, or through a single viewpoint, lead to biased conclusions or missed insights, reducing the value and accuracy of your concept testing efforts.

Solution: Share your findings with multiple stakeholders to ensure diverse viewpoints. Encourage collaborative analysis sessions, actively seeking out different perspectives to thoroughly interpret the results and minimize personal biases.

Selecting the right concept testing method for your product

You now understand what concept testing is and why it’s important. Next, let's focus on how to effectively apply this knowledge. In this section, we'll guide you through practical considerations to confidently design, structure, and analyze your concept tests.

Choosing the right concept testing methodology

Choose your testing method based on how mature your product concept is. Early-stage ideas benefit from simple monadic or comparative tests, while advanced prototypes require protomonadic tests. 

Consider factors like the available budget, development timeline, and the complexity of the idea you're testing.

Selecting survey components

Prioritize survey elements that directly support your key goals. For quick validation, rely on clear visuals and straightforward purchase-intent scales. 

To gain a deeper understanding of motivations or hesitations, include open-ended questions that encourage detailed feedback. Limit demographic questions to those genuinely affecting your results to avoid participant fatigue.

Structuring a concept testing survey

How you structure a concept testing survey directly influences data quality. Start surveys with non-challenging screening and demographic questions, then clearly present the concept. Follow with straightforward quantitative scales before concluding with open-ended questions. 

This sequencing builds participant comfort, ensuring more thoughtful, accurate responses.

[Info tip] Want to dive deeper into crafting effective concept testing questions? Check out our guide to writing concept testing questions for expert tips and real-world examples.

Analyzing and identifying the best concept

Analysis isn't just about identifying which concept "won," but why it performed best. Combine quantitative performance metrics – like appeal ratings – with qualitative responses. 

Pay attention to recurring themes, user excitement, or confusion signals. Clearly articulating these insights allows your team to act decisively, leveraging user feedback to refine the final product.

Ready to get started with concept testing?

Incorporating concept testing into your product development process can greatly enhance your chances of success and prevent costly failures. 

Lyssna can help you gather valuable feedback from your target audience with features like five second testing, first click testing, prototype testing, and preference testing, plus the ability to recruit from the participant panel.

Launch your first concept test

Ready to prevent costly mistakes and validate your ideas? Try Lyssna free and get actionable feedback in minutes.

Sign up for free

Sign up for free

Sign up for free

Frequently asked questions about concept testing

What is concept testing?

What are the steps for concept testing?

What are the different types of concept testing?